Image: Beach 13, digital photo 2

Abolish paid parking? Bad idea!

Giuliano Mingardo | Erasmus University Rotterdam Over the past two years, there has been a great deal of discussion and controversy surrounding paid parking in urban shopping districts. A rough summary of this discussion: two parties that cannot do without each other are struggling to communicate effectively with one another.

Giuliano Mingardo

October 05, 2015

On the one hand, there are retailers, developers and anyone who makes money from (physical) retail, who would like to see parking rates reduced or would prefer to abolish paid parking altogether. On the other hand, there are governments (mostly municipalities) and parking operators who have a different opinion about parking. What is the reason for these divergent opinions? Actually, it is quite simple: the first group is convinced that cheaper or free parking leads to more customers and sales. The second group is convinced that cheaper or free parking leads to mobility problems and less revenue. In this post, I make clear why abolishing paid parking is a bad idea in urban shopping areas.

 

The context

First, it is useful to know why the discussion around paid parking in urban shopping areas is a hot topic at all. The reason for this discussion is very simple: in recent years, (physical) retailers have had a very difficult time. The number of customers and turnover have fallen sharply, many retailers have used up their own reserves, some have gone bankrupt and many are still in financial trouble. As a result, they are against any measure that could threaten their business.It is well known within economics and retail that there are three main reasons for the malaise in retail:

 

1. The economic/financial crisis of the past 6-7 years, which is not completely over. This has meant that consumers have less money to spend and have become more careful with their spending;

 

2. The meteoric rise of the Internet and all forms of new technologies (social media, 3-D printing, etc.) in retail. This has not only led to a shift from the physical store to the internet store, but has led to a complete change in consumer behavior

 

3. Just when the demand for physical retail space is decreasing because of points 1 and 2, a lot of shopping areas have increased their supply of square meters of store. This, according to the basic economic law of supply and demand, leads to vacancy.

 

Paid parking and shopping

Despite the fact that parking has nothing at all to do with the above three points, this topic has been the subject of fierce debate among retailers, policymakers, developers and experts over the past two years. We have now reached the point where a number of (small) cities have made the decision to abolish paid parking, temporarily or permanently - see Winschoten and Harderwijk - and other cities are seriously considering introducing similar measures.There are four reasons why abolishing paid parking (or lowering the parking rate) is a bad idea in urban shopping areas:

 

1. It is antisocial policy. The concept "there is no such a thing as free parking" has been around for a long time, but apparently it hasn't gotten through to everyone yet. Parking costs money; a lot of money. And in the case of underground parking in inner-city areas, it costs even more money. It is not just about construction costs, but also about maintenance, cleaning costs, security, etc.... In the case of street parking and municipal garages, these costs are borne by the Municipality. Largely with tax money. If the costs are not paid by the user (motorist), they are paid from municipal budget. The more money the Municipality has to put into parking, the less money is available for other municipal tasks (e.g. public spaces, schools...). The less the motorist pays, the more the residents of the city have to pay. In doing so, residents are actually subsidizing motorists. Now if all the motorists are also residents of the Municipality or city where they park, then the above might not be so bad. But if the motorists live in another municipality (and pay their taxes there) then there is a subsidy from the residents of a city to the residents of other cities. This also means that a poor resident of the town (who probably does not have a car) is subsidizing the rich residents of another town. The rich surgeon who lives in the Vinex location outside the big city and uses his Porsche to go to town is subsidized by the family with two children who has a less than modal income. I find this particularly antisocial!

 

2. Abolishing paid parking does not work, c.q. it does not lead to more customers and sales for retailers. There is enough (scientific) evidence that free parking and the level of parking fees do not affect the number of customers and/or the turnover of stores. I am not only talking about studies from Erasmus University Rotterdam but also from other organizations such as: SOAB (2011), Rabobank (2013), DTZ Zadelhoff (2012), WPM (2015). All studies show, based on objective data, that there is hardly any relationship between parking and turnover. There are probably dozens of factors that influence how much money we spend, what products we buy and where we store. Parking is not one of those reasons. Therefore, it doesn't make sense to throw energy (and money) away to make parking free. If you absolutely must give something free, give people a free cup of coffee or something similar. NOTE: This does not mean that a city does not need parking at all; it just means that parking does not have to be free.

 

3. Abolishing paid parking leads to (more) mobility and financial problems. Parking is the only serious instrument a city has to steer and control (car) mobility. As with most products, when parking becomes free, you can expect more demand for parking (=cars). This does not necessarily mean more visitors, just more cars. Besides all the negative effects of more cars in the city (more traffic jams, pollution, insecurity...), free parking also leads to more people looking for parking spaces. Since capacity is limited, and it is very expensive to expand it, the result is that many motorists keep driving around looking for a spot. If these are retail customers, then I don't see the benefit of free retail parking. Instead, you want your customer inside, not driving around looking for a parking spot! Parking is a scarce commodity and the easiest (and often the best way) to regulate scarce goods is through price.

 

4. Free parking starts a vicious cycle that can have disastrous long-term consequences. This is probably the most underestimated effect of making parking free. A few ideas about what could happen:

  • First, it means you lose the revenue from parking (but not the costs, which remain) and you also lose your steering tool (how do you now regulate the hordes of visitors who come by car?).
  • Second, in the future, retailers will increasingly ask for free parking. So you will have to build even more (expensive) parking capacity without revenue. Good luck with that!
  • Third, all private parking operators will eventually leave cities where free parking is introduced or where rates are kept artificially low. This means that those shopping areas will eventually have less parking capacity or the Municipality will have to invest additional money to compensate the operators and/or take over their garage.
  • Finally, if it does turn out to work, how long do you think it will take before your competing neighborhood municipalities will do the same? If it works in your municipality, it will work in my municipality too! Result: policymakers have lost their steering tool and revenue, and entrepreneurs their (hypothetical) edge. Better, then, to invest in something that allows you to be permanently distinctive.

The only result a municipality gets out of implementing free parking in the long run is most likely a downtown overcrowded with cars and a financial disaster. And for what? For a non-effective and non-efficient way to boost downtown retail.

 

The Big Picture

Store owners, property owners/developers, parking operators and municipalities are not enemies of each other, they are entrepreneurs in the same business. Everyone has the same goal: everyone wants a vibrant and lively downtown full of people spending money in local stores. No city government benefits from an empty downtown with stores that are almost bankrupt. Neither do parking operators, since they make money from cars, not from people staying home and e-shopping. And don't forget the word "entrepreneurs"; parking is also a product/service of a business, just like selling clothes, shoes, televisions or the hospitality industry. Are the products in those stores free? No, they are not. So why should the parking operator (public or private) provide its product/service for free? It is a persistent misconception that cities that charge (high) parking rates are anti-car or unfriendly to visitors. Is Starbucks an anti-coffee company? Or customer-unfriendly? Is Apple an anti-IT company? Is BMW anti-car? No, most certainly not, but their products are very expensive. Yet no one complains about their prices. On the contrary, most people line up to buy those products.Want to attract more visitors to your city? Then stop complaining about (free) parking and start to think about the things that can really make your city attractive. I am not an expert on retail and city attractiveness, but I am an expert on parking, and as such, I can assure you that introducing free parking in the hope that more customers will come to town is a hopeless endeavor.

Back